Pages

Tuesday, October 27, 2015

Is Ben Carson Really a Psychopath?

I mean you know a lot of times he's been referred to as nuts but when you say it you don''t necessarily mean he's really literally a psychopath. 

Sure he says lots of crazy things about how the Jews could have avoided the Holocaust if there were just a working NRA in Germany at the time, and just the other day he compared abortion to slavery. 

Everything is either like the Holocaust, slavery, or abortion, to Ben Carson. 

With Carson's recent surge in the polls, a lot of the pundits and GOP establishment are ecstatic an telling us this is when it ends for Trump. First it was Iowa polls but now today a national poll had Carson up by a few-though still within the margin of error. 

http://fivethirtyeight.com/datalab/can-ben-carson-really-take-out-donald-trump/

But it's beginning to seem like this guy might really be crazy: I mean really. When he was asked about Trump calling him 'low energy' he admitted that now a days he's pretty 'relaxed' but there was a time when he was much more 'volatile.' 

This turns out to be when he was 14 and he would use knives, rocks, anything handy. It was a rather astonishing admission though at first blush Chuck Todd seemed nonplussed. 

So maybe this whole relaxed persona stems from a need to fight back against his scary inner volatility?

We remember that time he claimed he used a gun to heroically fight off a thief but then the story changed to where he told the guy with the gun 'You want the cashier, not me.''

http://www.vox.com/2015/10/8/9480797/ben-carson-gunman-popeyes

But these new revelations take us to a whole new level. 

"The more Ben Carson speaks, the more it becomes clear that he’s suffering from some kind of mental illness. His comments on guns alone have included everything from his historically false claim that the Holocaust was caused by gun control, to the assertion that he’s more offended by gun control than he is by a “body with bullet holes.” This all suggests that he suffers from paranoid violent fantasies. And after his recent admission on CNN about his consistently violent past, it may help explain his ongoing gun obsession."

"Carson was asked about his emotionless demeanor, which some have described as a catatonic while others have jokingly suggested that he’s asleep at all times. He refuted the notion that he’s too calm by pointing to his violent tendencies. He says that in his youth he attacked people with “rocks, and bricks, and baseball bats, and hammers.” He then went on to tell the story of how he once committed attempted murder by trying to stab his friend to death during a disagreement"

"Everyone has things from their youth they’re not proud of. But Ben Carson has revealed that during his youth he was apparently a murderous psychopath. People don’t magically recover from that kind of violent mental illness simply because they get older. While he appears to have willed himself into no longer committing acts of violence, he’s no doubt still suffering from his paranoid violent fantasies and his urges to kill. Perhaps that explains why he’s still so obsessed with guns, obsessed with Hitler, and obsessed with violence in general. In any other context, people would be calling for a violently mentally ill man like Ben Carson to seek treatment. Instead, republicans are calling for him to be President."

http://www.dailynewsbin.com/opinion/ben-carsons-shocking-past-which-includes-attempted-murder-suggests-hes-a-violent-psychopath/22924/

For more see this piece in Gawker.

http://gawker.com/ben-carson-has-plenty-of-energy-once-tried-to-stab-a-g-1738615515

I have mixed feelings about Trump losing his lead-it was just one national poll so it is premature to say he's no longer the leader. We will need confirmation as we have in Iowa.

My dream is for Trump to win the nomination or if not at least be a major factor deep into the primary next year.

But the GOP is hardly less of a joke because they now have someone with Ben Carson's description leading the party.

10 comments:

  1. "But it's beginning to seem like this guy might really be crazy:"

    Let's say he truly is 100% insane and will assuredly launch a full scale thermonuclear war his first day in office to force Jesus to rapture saved Christians such as himself, and destroy all the evil non-believers and heretics, so they all go to hell to burn in everlasting agony for all eternity.

    And let's say that if the GOP nominates him (how could they resist!) it maximizes the odds that the Democratic nominee wins, but there's still a 25% chance that Carson wins.

    What do you want to happen in that circumstance Mike? :^D

    ReplyDelete
  2. BTW, regarding Trump in Iowa, did you see this?:
    https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/post-politics/wp/2015/10/27/donald-trump-to-iowa-will-you-get-your-numbers-up-please/

    ReplyDelete
  3. BTW, I was thinking that a TRULY conservative immigration policy would be merit based: once the 13th and 14th amendments are repealed, we institute a merit system: and if it turns out you're a sub-optimal citizen (i.e. you don't really contribute enough to the game), then we let a more qualified individual take your place (maybe a PhD in biochemistry from India) and then tell you "You're FIRED!" and put your sorry ass on a barge and shove you out to sea with the other losers, slackers, dim-wits and freeloaders: telling the lot of you to get lost and never come back. Where you were born doesn't factor in. All that counts is how you contribute to the bottom line.

    I wonder how that message would sell to the GOP base? Lol.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'm thinking of Alec Baldwin's "brass balls" scene in Gengary Glen Ross. Have you seen it?

      "Put that coffee DOWN! Coffee's for closers, only."

      Lol.

      https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r6Lf8GtMe4M

      Delete
  4. If anything Ben Carson is more unpredictable than even Trump. The funny thing is that he's a Seventh Day Adventist and I know quite a bit about them: I was raised a SDA-I might have mentioned this.

    I was raised one, which is not to say I in any sense am one today. As I told you in our previous conversations on religion I'm an atheist

    What I do know is that SDA theology is totally apocalyptic based. It believes in an end times that will happen in America.

    SDAs are always looking for sings that America is now in the end times. The sign of the end times for SDAs is when the US government which had preached the secular ideology of separation of church and state suddenly is taken over by a theocracy that imposes a Sunday law.

    SDAs observe the Saturday Sabbath-like the Jews-and believe the day was wrongly changed by the Catholic Church to Sunday.

    One aspect of SDA theology is that the Catholic Church figures very large in it and not at all in a good way. The Catholic Church is 'the Beast' spoken about in Revelation.

    They take the prophecies of Revelation very seriously and literally and they see it all happening in the US.

    Now this theology just shows that the SDA religion was very much a product of time and place: like Mormonism, it appears in mid to late 19th century America

    So when I hear Trump mention Ben Carson's religion I kind of laugh as I know all too well about that religion.

    In all fainress, not everyone who is in the church is as nutso as Carson. Still, as my thumbnail sketch probably indicates, this is a pretty fervent set of beliefs that people who take things too far can really go off on the deep end on.

    I don't think you can fairly say that everyone who is a SDA is a psychopath, but I don think that for someone who is a psychopath it's a rather deadly brew for them to get into SDA theology.

    Maybe this is why he so opposes a Muslim as President. He fears a Muslim would bring about the End Times by enthroning a Sunday Law.

    SDAs paradoxically believe in separation of Church and State as they fear SDAs will be persecuted in a future US theocracy.

    ReplyDelete
  5. As to your question what would I want to happen, are you asking what I would want to happen in the GOP primary faced with a choice between Carson on the one hand and Jeb Bush or Marco Rubio on the other?

    Are you trying to get me to say that I'd rather Bush/Rubio? LOL.

    If so I will have to disappoint you. I'd still rather have Carson. My general principle at this point is anyone but Jeb/Rubio.

    But this is because I think the chances of anyone but Jeb'Rubio having a real chance is pretty farfetched!

    To me if the GOP is now ready to nominate someone as wildeyed as Ben who as Lindsay Graham says once tried to kill a man then I'm all for it.

    For one thing it will show just how far this party has gone. Secondly it will likely end up losing in a landslide as Bruce Bartlett argues.

    In a way to even talk about the Republican party now is anachronistic: the McCarthy mess shows that it's less a party now than a bunch of warring factions.

    Now I take your point. You're concern is that 25% is still a nontrivial possibility .

    I guess I'm a guy willing to take risks! But I just think that the status quo we've seen in recent years has been so dysfunctional is that something has to change.

    If the Far Right lunatics really have the votes to elect Ben Carson then that's what needs to happen.

    At some point the status quo is no longer worth preserving. I mean the status quo of the GOP the last 5 years.

    Also as crazy as President Ben could be on policy I don't know that it would be any worse than a President Jeb.

    See this is a weird case where uncertainty is even preferable. I know what the policies of a Jeb or Rubio would be and they would be awful.

    They would have the chance of nominating 2 or 3 SJC justices. They would totally destroy Obama's legacy and destroy what's left of a woman's right to choose.

    Meanwhile no immigration reform. So I know this for a fact. Ben is not really a mainstream GOPer at all and could even surprise to the upside like yesterday when he for a moment suggested federal funding of public schools-a huge GOP no-no.

    I already see a normal GOP President as the worst case scenario.

    My belief though is that Carson could never win the general. I doubt he can win the primary as he really is more an typical Iowa caucus winner.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Now that I've written so much I wish I put this in a blog post! Look for it.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I have a new post about Ben Carson' and Adventism.

    On Ben Carson's religion by someone raised a Seventh Day Adventist

    http://lastmenandovermen.blogspot.com/2015/10/on-ben-carsons-religious-faith-by.html

    ReplyDelete
  8. Glen Garry Glen Ross remains one of my favorite movies ever. Perhaps this is largely due to my history of a telemarker !LOL.

    Great movie. Anything with Kevin Spacey is great

    ReplyDelete
  9. Tom you should have seen me on Twitter. I gave Trump a pep talk. I said 'Buck up Mr. Trump, it's a marathon not a sprint. You have to expect a few polls not to go your way, it's the nature of a long campaign. Don't worry about Ben Carson, he has no legs beyond Iowa.'

    ReplyDelete