They just hated his press conference yesterday. Editorial after editorial in the WP today is beside itself that Obama didn't walk over broken glass. We have conservative Jennifer Rubin gloating, 'Ok, this is why the Republicans won.'
Dana Milbank:
“I hear you,” President Obama said to the voters who gave Democrats an electoral drubbing in Tuesday’s midterm elections.
Dana Milbank:
“I hear you,” President Obama said to the voters who gave Democrats an electoral drubbing in Tuesday’s midterm elections.
"But their message went in one presidential ear and out the other."
"The Republican victory was a political earthquake, giving the opposition party control of the Senate, expanding its House majority to a level not seen in generations and burying Democratic gubernatorial candidates."
"Yet when Obama fielded questions for an hour Wednesday afternoon, he spoke as if Tuesday had been but a minor irritation. He announced no changes in staff or policy, acknowledged no fault or error and expressed no contrition or regret. Though he had called Democrats’ 2010 losses a “shellacking,” he declined even to label Tuesday’s results."
"Obama declared that he would continue with plans for executive orders to expand legal status to undocumented immigrants — even though, minutes before Obama’s news conference, Senate Republican leader Mitch McConnell said that would be “like waving a red flag in front of a bull.” Obama repeated a familiar list of priorities — a minimum-wage hike, infrastructure and education spending, climate-change action — and brushed off various Republican proposals."
http://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/obama-seems-numb-to-this-shellacking/2014/11/05/e4873444-6548-11e4-bb14-4cfea1e742d5_story.html?hpid=z3
The Washington Post can't stand it-for years they've been on and on about Obama's 'failure to lead'-you have to understand what Tuesday was about to them. For the GOP it's vindication of obstruction, vindication of Obama hatred, vindication of everything they ever said about him. For the Very Serious People in the press it's vindication of all their complaint about 'failing to lead'-why doesn't he just come out on bended knee-that it's a black man would make him on his knees all the sweeter!
Then we have Obama's alleged progressive friend E.J. Dionne-who really isn't his friend-rubbing it in. This is worse than 2010! It's the worse election ever I guess.
http://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/ej-dionne-democrats-2014-defeat-is-worse-than-it-was-in-2010/2014/11/05/bbbdc1ce-6528-11e4-836c-83bc4f26eb67_story.html
This alleged 'earthquake' is all about the media feeling vindicated in its trite complaint about his leadership style.'
So how should he have reacted? If you can believe it, Milbank thinks he has something to learn from George W. Bush.
"President George W. Bush was rarely one to admit error, but on the day after the midterm “thumpin’ ” Republicans received eight years ago, he responded dramatically. Bush announced the ouster of defense chief Donald Rumsfeld and set in motion a new Iraq policy. He also offered a frank acknowledgment that everything had changed: “The election’s over and the Democrats won, and now we’re going to work together for two years to accomplish big objectives for the country.”
"Obama was blase by comparison. “Obviously, Republicans had a good night,” he said, but “beyond that, I’ll leave it to all of you and the professional pundits to pick through yesterday’s results.” The message that Obama took from the election, he said, was that Americans “want us to get the job done. All of us in both parties have a responsibility to address that sentiment.”
http://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/obama-seems-numb-to-this-shellacking/2014/11/05/e4873444-6548-11e4-bb14-4cfea1e742d5_story.html?hpid=z3
Meanwhile Ed Rogers held up Bill Clinton as the model for how you respond to a 'shellacking.'
http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/post-partisan/wp/2014/11/05/the-insiders-no-signals-that-president-obama-gets-it/
Yes, Lawrence O'Donnell looked back on how Clinton responded last night-remember that he worked for Clinton in 1994. Clinton offered what the blood thirsty press wants-mea culpas.
Actually what Clinton apologized for was raising rich people's taxes. He blamed it on congressional Democrats. We keep hearing how low a regard Congressional Democrats hold Obama in. I'm sure Clinton's Democrats held him in much higher regard after he threw them under the bus.
At the end of the day what did the VSP at WP and elsewhere want? In a word blood. They wanted the President on his knees. Major heartfelt kudos to him for not giving it to them.
P.S. Tuesday wasn't quite the earthquake the VSP say it was. My guess, we'll have forgotten this whole narrative by 2016. Yes, for now the GOP's cynical strategy worked but this was an off year election which is totally different from a Presidential year. My guess is that we'll have a Democratic wave in 2016 that sweeps away this Republican wave.
Hey Mike
ReplyDeleteSome really good political analysis and commentary in your last few posts. I think you are spot on.
I hate that the repubs have so much to gloat over but there is no doubt that liberal ideas are winning (more to the point... extreme conservative ideas are losing) , even in red states. These guys are just like those dancing DBs who get a meaningless interception in the 4th after being torched 3 times. Every election is a wave, the beginning of a new permanent conservative majority or some such thing.
These guys are really gonna show how much work they want to get done. I predict the first thing they will do in January is vote on Obama care repeal....... for the 700th time.
They might have a replacement idea and if they do it will look almost exactly like everything in the ACA (since the health insurers wrote most of the ACA). Where it is likely to differ is in relieving insurers form having to take everyone (which will make it a complete non starter for the average person) and in removing the mandate to purchase (making it a non starter with the insurers..... they are the ones that want everyone in)
They may regret getting the center stage by this time next year.
Hi Greg, great to hear from you again. It's been awhile but it sounds like you keep reading even when you don't weigh in.
ReplyDeleteI agree that their first act will be another ACA repeal vote. What they will try to do in the long run is maybe nibble around the edges.
The establishment Republicans on Wall Street are hoping they won't go crazy again-no more debt ceiling chicken or shutting down the government, they hope.
http://www.nytimes.com/2014/11/06/business/republican-election-victory-seen-as-positive-for-business-but-others-temper-expectations.html?rref=business&module=ArrowsNav&contentCollection=The%20Upshot&action=keypress®ion=FixedLeft&pgtype=article&_r=0
Everything we know about the Republicans when they get a little power over the past 20 years suggests they'll mess this up too.
I maintain that no matter what, 2016 will be a good year for the Dems again. The reality is that the GOP is just a regional party now that can win Congress-mostly the House during midterms but not the White House.
http://mwbdvjh.muse.jhu.edu/journals/new_labor_forum/v019/19.3.schaller.pdf
Schaller who I linked above is a very good political philosopher. This is his new book-not out till next year, unfortunately, that talks about how the GOP is now a regional party that dominates the House-after for years being a Presidential party that was out of the House for 40 years.
ReplyDeletehttp://www.amazon.com/Stronghold-Republicans-Captured-Congress-Surrendered/dp/0300172036/ref=sr_1_1?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1415252659&sr=1-1&keywords=thomas+schaller+the+stronghold
I'm doing more reading/listening and less talking!
ReplyDeleteYou are right about Wall St not liking the extreme hysteria around debt ceiling/shutdown. McConnell/Boehner going to have his hands full keeping the crazies in check.... again.
Yes 2016 looks to be very much against the GOP..... but in general every year more of their ardent supporters die and are replaced in the voting block with more liberal voters. Demographics are badly against the current GOP ideas as we go on.
That sounds like an interesting book and it sounds about right. Small town/local politics is about the only place they have a chance to be victorious, so holding the house and state govts will be their likely areas of success.
John Oliver had a great show about state politics being where all the real action is these days. Thanks to ALEC the GOP is putting more efforts there and its kind of under the radar. Check it out. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aIMgfBZrrZ8